Global Temperatures Global Troposphere Temperatures click here For full size []]
Providing Insight
Into Climate Change
Climate Models
Technical Rating
star Easy
starstar Harder
starstarstar Most Difficult
54 Articles

Testing the Tropical 200-300 mbar Warming Rate in Climate Models

Technical Rating: star star
The tropical warming rate in climate models in the 200-300 mbar (9 to 12 km altitude) is compared to weather balloon measurement at a fundamental test of the models. Dr. McKirtick and Dr. Christy show that the average trend of the measurements is only about half of the climate models. They report a discrepancy across all runs of all models, taking the form of a warming bias at a sufficiently strong rate as to reject the hypothesis that the models are realistic. This means that the water vapour feedback is too strong in the models, and that they overestimate the warming due to greenhouse gas emissions.

Testimony of Dr. John Christy on Climate Science March 29, 2017

Technical Rating: star
Dr. John Christy gave this testimony to a hearing of the Committee on Science, Space and Technology of the US House of Representatives on 29 March 2017. He writes " When the “scientific method” is applied to the output from climate models of the IPCC AR5, specifically the bulk atmospheric temperature trends since 1979 ..., I demonstrate that the consensus of the models fails the test to match the real-world observations by a significant margin. He recommends the Congress to "fund credible “Red Teams” that look at issues such as natural variability, the failure of climate models and the huge benefits to society from affordable energy, carbon-based and otherwise."

The Canadian Climate Model's Epic Failure

Technical Rating: star
The Canadian climate model CanESM2 produces one of the most extreme warming projections of all the 30 models evaluated by the IPCC. The model badly fails to match the surface and atmosphere temperature observations, both globally, regionally. The mid-troposphere (400 mbar) global model temperature warming rate (1979 to 2015) is 287% of the weather balloon trend, and 532% of the satellite trend. The mid-troposphere (400 mbar) tropical (20 N to 20 S) model warming rate is 447% of the average of the satellite and balloon observations. This is an updated report to include 2015 data.

Testimony of Dr. John Christy - U.S. House Committee on Science, Space & Technology

Technical Rating: star
Climatologist Dr. John Christy discusses the temperature datasets used to study climate and shows that satellite temperature measurements are superior to land based measurements that are contaminated by the effects of urbanization. Comparing the multi-model mean to satellites and weather balloon data, the models over-warm the tropical atmosphere by a factor of 3.2 and over-warm the global atmosphere by a factor of 2.5 over the last 37 years. Christy shows that the new NOAA seawater temperature dataset, which added more warming from 1990, now shows more warming than the Hadley Centre HadCRUT4 seawater temperature dataset, both of which show more warming that the air near the sea surface.

Earth’s Top of Atmosphere Energy Imbalance in Climate Models

Technical Rating: star star
Bob Tisdale's analysis of climate models' shows that there is no agreement on the magnitude of Earth's top-of-atmosphere energy imbalance in the models. There are even wider disagreements in the three calculated components that make up that energy budget, how they evolved in the past, and how they may evolve in the future. This indicates there is little agreement in the modeled processes and physics that contribute to global warming.

web design & development by: